Evidence-Based GEO / AI Search Optimization Audit
Audit content for AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity citability using primary-source evidence — including why llms.txt isn't the ranking lever most GEO advice claims it is.
Every GEO checklist tells you to create an llms.txt file. Google's own documentation says Google Search ignores it completely, and a 300,000-domain study found only 1 of the top 50 AI-cited sites even has one — so which advice are you actually going to trust?
Who it's for: SEO specialists expanding into AI search optimization, content marketers optimizing for AI Overviews and ChatGPT citations, in-house marketing teams tired of contradictory GEO advice, agencies needing a defensible, source-cited GEO methodology for client reports, technical marketers who want crawler-access and rendering checks alongside content scoring
Example
"Run a GEO audit on our pricing page" → A GEO-ANALYSIS.md with a 0-100 readiness score, separate scores for Google AI Overviews vs. AI Mode vs. ChatGPT vs. Perplexity, an AI crawler access report from robots.txt, an evidence-based llms.txt assessment that doesn't oversell its impact, specific 134-167 word passages flagged for citability, and the top 5 highest-impact changes ranked by effort
CLAUDE.md Template
New here? 3-minute setup guide → | Already set up? Copy the template below.
npx ccplaybooks add evidence-based-geo-audit# Evidence-Based GEO / AI Search Optimization Audit
## Your Role
You audit and optimize content for AI Overviews, ChatGPT web search, Perplexity, and other AI-powered search experiences — grounded in what's actually been verified to work, not what's commonly repeated in GEO advice.
**Google's own position**: optimizing for generative AI search is still SEO. GEO and AEO are, in Google's framing, rebranded labels for the same underlying work. When community recommendations contradict a primary source (Google's documentation, a named Google engineer, a large-sample study), defer to the primary source and say so explicitly in the audit — don't quietly average the two.
Frame every finding as **SEO fundamentals applied to AI-search surfaces**, not as a separate, exotic discipline.
---
Get new playbooks like this one
One email a week with new Claude Code workflows. Free, like everything here.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What This Does
Runs a structured audit of how citable a page is to AI search systems — Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, ChatGPT web search, and Perplexity — scored across five weighted criteria: citability, structural readability, multi-modal content, authority signals, and technical accessibility.
What sets this apart from typical GEO advice is the evidence discipline: every non-obvious claim traces to a named primary source (Google's own documentation, specific Google engineers, or large-sample third-party studies), and it explicitly corrects the most common GEO myth — that llms.txt is a ranking lever. It isn't, and Google's docs say so directly.
Quick Start
Step 1: Create a Project Folder
mkdir geo-audit && cd geo-audit
Step 2: Download the Template
Click Download above, then:
mv ~/Downloads/CLAUDE.md ./
Step 3: Run an Audit
claude
Then ask: "Run a GEO audit on [url or page content]"
The Five Scoring Criteria
| Criterion | Weight | What it checks |
|---|---|---|
| Citability | 25% | Self-contained 134-167 word answer blocks, direct answers up front, specific sourced data |
| Structural readability | 20% | Heading hierarchy, question-based headers, short paragraphs, tables and lists |
| Multi-modal content | 15% | Images, video, infographics, interactive elements |
| Authority & brand signals | 20% | Author credentials, publish/update dates, recency, entity presence (Wikipedia, Reddit, YouTube) |
| Technical accessibility | 20% | Server-side rendering, AI crawler access, llms.txt, RSL licensing |
The llms.txt Myth, Corrected
| Source | What they actually said |
|---|---|
| Google's AI optimization guide | Google Search ignores llms.txt entirely — it "won't harm (nor help)" rankings |
| John Mueller (Google) | Called it "a dead end"; compared it to deprecated meta keywords |
| SE Ranking, 300k-domain study | Only 1 of the top 50 AI-cited domains had an llms.txt |
| OtterlyAI server-log audit | 0.1% of AI-bot traffic requests it |
It does matter for AI coding agents reading developer documentation — just not for AI search citation. The audit reports presence without pretending it's a ranking factor.
Tips & Best Practices
- Recency is one of the highest-leverage levers available. Content under 3 months old is roughly 3x more likely to be cited than older content, and pages stale for 6+ months start losing citation eligibility — a scheduled refresh program often beats a full rewrite.
- Score Google AI Overviews and AI Mode separately. They're different citation engines that agree on conclusions ~86% of the time but cite the same URL only ~13.7% of the time — optimizing for one doesn't automatically cover the other.
- Server-side rendering is a hard requirement, not a nice-to-have. AI crawlers don't execute JavaScript — client-only rendered content is frequently invisible to them regardless of how good the content itself is.
- Brand mentions beat backlinks for AI visibility. YouTube and Reddit mentions correlate far more strongly with AI citation than Domain Rating does (Ahrefs study) — if link building isn't moving the needle on AI visibility, that's expected, not a sign something's broken.
- User-triggered AI fetchers ignore robots.txt by design. Google-Agent, Google-NotebookLM, and ChatGPT-User act on a specific user's behalf and cannot be blocked via robots.txt — if access control matters here, it needs to happen server-side.
Limitations
- Several cited statistics are third-party-reported (Ahrefs, SE Ranking, OtterlyAI) rather than confirmed by the platform owners — the audit flags which is which, and that distinction should be preserved when sharing findings
- GEO measurement is inherently noisier than traditional rank tracking — treat scores as directional, not a precise metric to optimize to the decimal point
- Optional integration with DataForSEO's AI-optimization tools exists for real-time ChatGPT/LLM mention tracking, but the core audit works fully without any paid API