Home
cd ../playbooks
Marketing & ContentAdvanced

Evidence-Based GEO / AI Search Optimization Audit

Audit content for AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity citability using primary-source evidence — including why llms.txt isn't the ranking lever most GEO advice claims it is.

10 minutes
By AgriciDanielSource
#geo#aeo#ai-search#chatgpt-seo#ai-overviews#perplexity#llms-txt#generative-engine-optimization#seo

Every GEO checklist tells you to create an llms.txt file. Google's own documentation says Google Search ignores it completely, and a 300,000-domain study found only 1 of the top 50 AI-cited sites even has one — so which advice are you actually going to trust?

Who it's for: SEO specialists expanding into AI search optimization, content marketers optimizing for AI Overviews and ChatGPT citations, in-house marketing teams tired of contradictory GEO advice, agencies needing a defensible, source-cited GEO methodology for client reports, technical marketers who want crawler-access and rendering checks alongside content scoring

Example

"Run a GEO audit on our pricing page" → A GEO-ANALYSIS.md with a 0-100 readiness score, separate scores for Google AI Overviews vs. AI Mode vs. ChatGPT vs. Perplexity, an AI crawler access report from robots.txt, an evidence-based llms.txt assessment that doesn't oversell its impact, specific 134-167 word passages flagged for citability, and the top 5 highest-impact changes ranked by effort

CLAUDE.md Template

New here? 3-minute setup guide → | Already set up? Copy the template below.

Or install from your terminal:
npx ccplaybooks add evidence-based-geo-audit
# Evidence-Based GEO / AI Search Optimization Audit

## Your Role

You audit and optimize content for AI Overviews, ChatGPT web search, Perplexity, and other AI-powered search experiences — grounded in what's actually been verified to work, not what's commonly repeated in GEO advice.

**Google's own position**: optimizing for generative AI search is still SEO. GEO and AEO are, in Google's framing, rebranded labels for the same underlying work. When community recommendations contradict a primary source (Google's documentation, a named Google engineer, a large-sample study), defer to the primary source and say so explicitly in the audit — don't quietly average the two.

Frame every finding as **SEO fundamentals applied to AI-search surfaces**, not as a separate, exotic discipline.

---

Get new playbooks like this one

One email a week with new Claude Code workflows. Free, like everything here.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

README.md

What This Does

Runs a structured audit of how citable a page is to AI search systems — Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, ChatGPT web search, and Perplexity — scored across five weighted criteria: citability, structural readability, multi-modal content, authority signals, and technical accessibility.

What sets this apart from typical GEO advice is the evidence discipline: every non-obvious claim traces to a named primary source (Google's own documentation, specific Google engineers, or large-sample third-party studies), and it explicitly corrects the most common GEO myth — that llms.txt is a ranking lever. It isn't, and Google's docs say so directly.


Quick Start

Step 1: Create a Project Folder

mkdir geo-audit && cd geo-audit

Step 2: Download the Template

Click Download above, then:

mv ~/Downloads/CLAUDE.md ./

Step 3: Run an Audit

claude

Then ask: "Run a GEO audit on [url or page content]"


The Five Scoring Criteria

Criterion Weight What it checks
Citability 25% Self-contained 134-167 word answer blocks, direct answers up front, specific sourced data
Structural readability 20% Heading hierarchy, question-based headers, short paragraphs, tables and lists
Multi-modal content 15% Images, video, infographics, interactive elements
Authority & brand signals 20% Author credentials, publish/update dates, recency, entity presence (Wikipedia, Reddit, YouTube)
Technical accessibility 20% Server-side rendering, AI crawler access, llms.txt, RSL licensing

The llms.txt Myth, Corrected

Source What they actually said
Google's AI optimization guide Google Search ignores llms.txt entirely — it "won't harm (nor help)" rankings
John Mueller (Google) Called it "a dead end"; compared it to deprecated meta keywords
SE Ranking, 300k-domain study Only 1 of the top 50 AI-cited domains had an llms.txt
OtterlyAI server-log audit 0.1% of AI-bot traffic requests it

It does matter for AI coding agents reading developer documentation — just not for AI search citation. The audit reports presence without pretending it's a ranking factor.

Tips & Best Practices

  • Recency is one of the highest-leverage levers available. Content under 3 months old is roughly 3x more likely to be cited than older content, and pages stale for 6+ months start losing citation eligibility — a scheduled refresh program often beats a full rewrite.
  • Score Google AI Overviews and AI Mode separately. They're different citation engines that agree on conclusions ~86% of the time but cite the same URL only ~13.7% of the time — optimizing for one doesn't automatically cover the other.
  • Server-side rendering is a hard requirement, not a nice-to-have. AI crawlers don't execute JavaScript — client-only rendered content is frequently invisible to them regardless of how good the content itself is.
  • Brand mentions beat backlinks for AI visibility. YouTube and Reddit mentions correlate far more strongly with AI citation than Domain Rating does (Ahrefs study) — if link building isn't moving the needle on AI visibility, that's expected, not a sign something's broken.
  • User-triggered AI fetchers ignore robots.txt by design. Google-Agent, Google-NotebookLM, and ChatGPT-User act on a specific user's behalf and cannot be blocked via robots.txt — if access control matters here, it needs to happen server-side.

Limitations

  • Several cited statistics are third-party-reported (Ahrefs, SE Ranking, OtterlyAI) rather than confirmed by the platform owners — the audit flags which is which, and that distinction should be preserved when sharing findings
  • GEO measurement is inherently noisier than traditional rank tracking — treat scores as directional, not a precise metric to optimize to the decimal point
  • Optional integration with DataForSEO's AI-optimization tools exists for real-time ChatGPT/LLM mention tracking, but the core audit works fully without any paid API

$Related Playbooks

Marketing & Content

Hreflang Check

Audit hreflang tags.

15 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

Facebook & Meta Ads Manager

Automate Facebook and Instagram advertising campaigns, audience targeting, and performance optimization

10 minutes
Advanced
Marketing & Content

Google Ads Campaign Manager

Google Ads campaign management - campaign setup, keyword research, bid optimization, and performance reporting

10 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

Google Ads Conversion Audit

Audit and fix Google Ads conversion tracking issues using Claude Code with browser automation - find misconfigurations that experts miss.

15 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

Firecrawl Brand Asset Collector

Collect a named organization's existing logo, colors, fonts, and homepage messaging from its website for a deck or document, with sources and no invented assets

10 minutes
Beginner
Marketing & Content

Firecrawl SEO Audit: Evidence-Backed Fixes

Audit pages for SEO metadata, headings, canonicals, schema, and link issues using the actual page HTML, with prioritized fixes and unverified checks kept separate

10 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

Free Backlink Opportunity Finder

Give Claude a website URL and get a verified list of relevant backlink opportunities you can pursue for free, with the exact page to link to and how to ask

5 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

GEO Audit: Score Your Site for AI Search Citation

A full Generative Engine Optimization audit that crawls a site, scores it 0-100 across six weighted categories, and returns a prioritized 30-day fix list

10 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

AI Citability Scoring: Make Your Pages Quotable

Score any page 0-100 on how likely ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini are to quote it, with block-level rewrites for the passages that score worst

10 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

GEO Content Quality: Score Your Pages on E-E-A-T

Grade any page on Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness, then get the specific rewrites that make AI engines trust it enough to cite

10 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

GEO Platform Optimizer: Tune for Each AI Engine Separately

Five separate audits for Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Bing Copilot, each with its own checklist and 0-100 rubric

10 minutes
Intermediate
Marketing & Content

Form CRO

Optimize lead capture, contact, demo, application, and survey forms for maximum completion rates.

10 minutes
Intermediate

Browse all Marketing & Content playbooks →